MakeUp Eraser vs. Cleansing Balm: Which Is Better for Removing Waterproof Makeup?

Quick answer

For waterproof makeup, both a MakeUp Eraser reusable towel and a cleansing balm can work, but they suit different needs. The MakeUp Eraser removes makeup with just water and is gentle and eco-friendly, while a cleansing balm uses oils to break down stubborn formulas. Your choice depends on your skin type, makeup habits, and preference for a water-only routine.

Removing waterproof makeup can be a challenge. Mascara, long-wear foundation, and liquid lipsticks are designed to stay put, so they often require extra effort. Two popular approaches are reusable makeup remover towels like the MakeUp Eraser and cleansing balms. Each has its strengths, and the right pick depends on your skin and routine.

In this comparison, we'll look at how these options work, their trade-offs, and who they suit best. We'll also highlight specific MakeUp Eraser products that can help you decide.

How MakeUp Eraser towels remove waterproof makeup

MakeUp Eraser towels are made from a special polyester microfiber that traps makeup, oil, and dirt. You simply wet the towel with warm water and gently wipe your face. The fibers lift makeup away without the need for cleansers or scrubbing. This makes them a convenient, eco-friendly option that reduces waste from disposable wipes.

Many users find that a MakeUp Eraser towel effectively removes waterproof mascara and long-wear makeup. The key is to use a soft, gentle motion and let the towel do the work. Since no cleansing balm is involved, this method is ideal for those who prefer a minimalist routine or have sensitive skin that reacts to oils.

• Use a clean section of the towel for each area to avoid spreading makeup.
• Rinse the towel thoroughly after each use and wash it in the machine regularly.

How cleansing balms work

Cleansing balms are oil-based formulas that melt makeup on contact. They are especially effective at breaking down waterproof and long-wear products because oil dissolves oil-based ingredients. After massaging the balm onto dry skin, you add water to emulsify it and rinse away.

Balms can be very thorough, but they often require a second cleanse to remove residue. They also add a step to your routine and may not be suitable for oily or acne-prone skin if not rinsed well. However, for heavy makeup or occasions when you need a deep clean, a balm can be a reliable choice.

• Always follow with a gentle cleanser if you use a balm to ensure no residue remains.

Trade-offs: towel vs. balm

The main trade-off is between convenience and thoroughness. A MakeUp Eraser towel is quick, reusable, and requires no additional products. It's also gentle and travel-friendly. On the other hand, a cleansing balm may offer a more thorough breakdown of stubborn makeup, but it adds cost, time, and potential residue.

Another factor is environmental impact. Reusable towels like the MakeUp Eraser reduce waste compared to single-use wipes and cotton rounds. Balms often come in plastic packaging and may contain ingredients you'd rather avoid. If sustainability is a priority, the towel has an edge.

Skin type also matters. If you have dry or sensitive skin, a towel with just water can be very soothing. If you have oily skin, a balm might not be ideal unless you double cleanse. Consider your skin's reaction and your willingness to follow a multi-step routine.

• For occasional heavy makeup, a balm may be worth the extra step.
• For daily wear and eco-conscious routines, a reusable towel is a solid choice.

How to choose the right MakeUp Eraser set

If you decide to try a MakeUp Eraser towel, you can choose from several 7-Day Sets. These sets include seven reusable pads, giving you a fresh cloth for each day of the week. This is convenient for maintaining hygiene and ensures you always have a clean towel ready.

For a classic look, the 7-Day Set Classics offers seven soft cloths that remove all types of makeup, including waterproof formulas, using only water. If you prefer a neutral palette, the 7-Day Set Neutrals provides seven pads in neutral tones. Both are priced at $12.50, offering good value compared to buying individual cloths.

Limited-edition sets like the Coconut 7-Day Set and Counting Sheep 7-Day Set add a fun design to your routine. Each includes seven reusable pads that gently wipe away makeup, dirt, and oil with just water. These sets cost $14.00 and are machine washable for long-lasting use.

• Rotate your pads daily and wash them at the end of the week to keep your routine hygienic.

Trade-offs at a glance

• Waterproof mascara removal: MakeUp Eraser towels need a gentle wipe with warm water; balms melt mascara with oils. If you hate tugging at lashes, a towel is gentler; for stubborn formulas, a balm may be more thorough.
• Skin sensitivity: Towels use only water, avoiding oils and fragrances; balms may contain ingredients that irritate sensitive skin. Sensitive skin often does better with a towel; patch-test any balm first.
• Environmental impact: Reusable towels cut waste from wipes and cotton rounds; balms add packaging waste. If sustainability is key, a towel like the MakeUp Eraser is the greener choice.
• Cost over time: A 7-Day Set costs about $12.50–$14.00 and lasts for months; balms need repurchasing regularly. Towels save money in the long run, especially for daily users.

MakeUp Eraser 7-Day Set options at a glance

• 7-Day Set Classics: Includes seven cloths for each day of the week, promoting a consistent and hygienic routine. Designed to remove all types of makeup, including waterproof formulas, using only water. Machine washable. This set is a straightforward choice if you want a reliable, water-only solution for daily waterproof makeup removal.
• 7-Day Set Neutrals: Seven soft, reusable pads in neutral tones for each day of the week. Designed to remove makeup with just water. Reusable and machine-washable. If you prefer a subtle color palette, this set offers the same functionality with a neutral aesthetic that fits any bathroom.
• Coconut 7-Day Set: Limited-edition set with seven cloths featuring a coconut-inspired design. Gently removes makeup and dirt with just water. Eco-friendly and reusable. This set adds a touch of fun to your routine while still providing effective, water-only makeup removal for the whole week.
• Counting Sheep 7-Day Set: Seven reusable pads in a charming Counting Sheep design. Gently wipes away makeup, dirt, and oil with just water. Helps reduce waste from disposable wipes. A whimsical option that encourages a zero-waste habit, perfect for those who want a playful yet practical makeup remover.

Who should choose which?

Best for

• People who want a quick, water-only routine without extra products.
• Eco-conscious users who want to reduce waste from disposable wipes and cotton rounds.
• Those with sensitive skin that reacts to oils or fragrances in balms.

Not for

• People who prefer a deep oil-based cleanse for heavy, all-day waterproof makeup.
• Those who don't want to wash and dry reusable towels regularly.

Both MakeUp Eraser towels and cleansing balms can remove waterproof makeup, but they serve different preferences. If you value simplicity, gentleness, and sustainability, a reusable towel from a 7-Day Set is a practical pick. If you need extra cleansing power for heavy makeup, a balm might be your ally. Consider your skin type and routine to make the best choice.